3 Reasons to Run from Debt Settlement Companies

Fiscal Liberty is a blog devoted to Personal Finance, Controlling Your Debt and Obtaining Financial Independence. Be the first to know when we publish new stuff: Subscribe to our RSS feed or via email

You may have seen ads on TV featuring companies that claim they can “repair” your credit. They tell you that you won’t even have to pay all that you owe to creditors because they’ll negotiate your debt down to a smaller percentage.

First of all, only you can “fix” your credit. If you have a poor rating, it won’t be easy to get it back up to a decent rating and it will take time. There’s no quick fixes when it comes to credit repair. If you’ve been thinking of taking advantage of one of these offers of debt settlement, here’s 3 reasons to run from debt settlement companies and rethink your options:

1. Your credit rating will plummet. Many of these debt negotiators will advise you to no longer take creditors’ phone calls. They’ll tell you not to make any payments. Meanwhile, your phone is probably ringing off the hook with creditors on the other end of the line, some of whom will undoubtedly threaten legal action. While the debt settlement company is waiting for you to get so behind in your bills before they make a move, your credit rating is dropping like a lead weight. And who wants to deal with all those harassing phone calls?

2. Many of them are scams. This isn’t to say all of the debt settlement industry is a scam, but it’s sure full of scam artists. From personal experience, I can tell you that one such company offered to sign me up without asking how I was going to make monthly payments. They simply said, this is what you’ll pay per month, but they didn’t know if I was employed, unemployed, what I made, etc. And they didn’t care. All they wanted was their exorbitant fee upfront before they’d lift a single finger to do anything about helping me with my debt. Besides, although a lot of consumers aren’t aware of this, they can negotiate with credit card companies themselves, without having to pay a middleman. But you can’t go into the negotiation pool with no life jacket; this requires a lot of research (because credit card companies often don’t want to cooperate with you on this) and sometimes an attorney.   

3. It doesn’t allow YOU to take full responsibility. I know this may be an unpopular view, but if you only have to pay back 50% of what you “owe,” how do you claim responsibility for all of your debt? I know that interest fees are a huge part of credit card balances and only having to pay back some of your enormous debt certainly looks attractive, so much of this will depend on how much you actually have to pay back. Someone who’s $25,000 in debt may have a different view that someone who’s $100,000 in the hole. But in the end, it’s all debt that you wracked up and part of being financially mature and responsible is being able to say “Hey, this is my debt, this is money I spent and now I’m going to be in charge of it and pay it back.”

If you still decide to go the debt settlement route, I can’t stress enough how important it is to do your homework and thoroughly check the company out. Or, you can go down a path that I know works and that’s dealing with a debt management company. No, your debt won’t get slashed by 50%, but your interest rates will be lowered by a significant margin, you’ll receive financial education and counseling as part of the program and you won’t have to avoid your creditors. Again though, check out a debt management company’s reputation before you sign up and then get on the way to being debt-free.